Heat Pump vs. Furnace in 2026: The $2,000 Credit Is Gone
2026 equipment year · home energy
The $2,000 federal heat pump tax credit is gone. Section 25C ended for property placed in service after December 31, 2025, under the July 2025 budget law, and nothing has reinstated it for 2026. So the real comparison for a system bought now is installed price plus ten years of fuel, against a furnace and air conditioner that also lost their credits.
At national average fuel prices, an efficient heat pump costs about $265 a year more to run than a 92% gas furnace in a 50 MMBtu heating climate, and roughly $1,650 more over ten years after installation. House by house, that flips: propane, oil, expensive gas, cheap electricity or a cooling system that is already failing all move the answer.
Key takeaways
- Section 25C and section 25D both ended for work done after December 31, 2025. A 2026 invoice cannot support a 2026 federal efficiency credit, whatever a quote or a cost guide still prints.
- Installed cost has narrowed: heat pumps run roughly $12,000 to $15,000, a gas furnace with air conditioning $13,000 to $16,000, because the heat pump replaces both machines.
- Operating cost decides it, and it depends on two prices you can look up: your electricity rate and your gas or propane rate. The national averages favor gas; a propane or oil house usually favors the heat pump.
- State rebate money from the 2022 climate law still exists in about ten states and DC, but California closed its single-family round in February 2026 and Texas has not launched.
Every heat pump cost page published before 2025 ended with the same line: subtract $2,000 for the federal credit. That line is now wrong, and it is still being printed by contractors and cost guides in late 2026, which is the first thing to check before you sign anything. What follows is the comparison without the credit, using published install ranges, EIA fuel prices for August 2026 and the efficiency ratings that actually appear on equipment sold this year.
The credit that no longer exists
Section 25C, the energy efficient home improvement credit, paid 30% of a qualifying heat pump's cost up to $2,000 a year. It had no lifetime cap, so a household replacing a heat pump and a water heater in different years could collect it twice. Section 25D paid 30% of geothermal and solar with no dollar ceiling. Section 25C was scheduled to run through 2032 and 25D through 2034.
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, moved both termination dates to December 31, 2025. The IRS confirmed the change in Fact Sheet 2025-05 and repeated it in the 2025 Form 5695 instructions: no credit for property placed in service after December 31, 2025, and no credit for residential clean energy expenditures made after that date. The manufacturer reporting requirement that applied to 2025 purchases was dropped entirely because the credit had already ended.
Two consequences follow. If your system was installed and operating by December 31, 2025, you can still claim the credit on your 2025 return, which you would file by April 2027 with an extension. If the equipment was installed in 2026, there is no federal credit, no matter how efficient it is. A contractor who says otherwise is either confused about the law or quoting a page he has not reread.
Several 2026 cost guides still display "25C credit — minus $2,000" in their tables, and at least one of them was updated in November 2026. If a quote shows that line, ask which credit it refers to. There is no residential federal heat pump credit for 2026 installations; a state or utility rebate is a different program with its own rules.
What each system costs installed in 2026
The comparison only works if you compare like with like. A heat pump heats and cools, so its honest competitor is a furnace plus an air conditioner, not a furnace alone. The ranges below come from installer-reported project data and national cost surveys; your market can sit outside them by thousands.
| System | Installed cost | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Heat pump, ducted, standard efficiency | $12,000–$15,000 | Heats and cools with one outdoor unit |
| Heat pump, cold-climate rated | $12,000–$32,500 | Heats and cools; holds capacity below 5°F |
| Gas furnace plus air conditioner | $13,000–$16,000 | Heats and cools with two machines |
| Gas furnace only | $6,500–$9,000 | Heats; cooling is separate |
| Ductless mini-split, per zone | $4,000–$7,500 | Heats and cools one room or area |
Three add-ons move a quote more than the equipment choice does. Electrical work to support a heat pump's compressor and backup strips can add $1,000 to $3,000 in an older house. Duct sealing or a plenum rebuild adds $1,500 to $4,000 if the existing ducts leak badly, which hurts a heat pump more than a furnace because the air it delivers is cooler. And a dual-fuel installation that keeps a furnace as backup adds $3,000 to $6,000, mostly for controls and the second fuel connection.
Run your own ten years
The calculator converts a heating and cooling load into fuel, then fuel into dollars at your prices. Defaults are EIA national averages for August 2026: 18.2 cents per kilowatt-hour of residential electricity and $1.61 per therm of residential natural gas. Change them to your own bill and your own quote.
Ten-year cost calculator
Heat pump vs. furnace and AC, with your prices
Heating and cooling demand are annual totals. A 2,000 sq ft house in a mixed climate is usually 45 to 60 MMBtu of heat and 15 to 25 MMBtu of cooling.
Propane and oil: convert to $ per therm first. Multiply the propane price per gallon by 1.09, or the heating oil price per gallon by 0.72, and enter the result. Updates as you type.
On these numbers the furnace and AC come out ahead by $1,647 over ten years.
The fuel math, worked out
A heat pump's efficiency is a ratio, not a percentage, and that trips up most comparisons. HSPF2 measures Btu of heat delivered per watt-hour of electricity. An HSPF2 of 8.5 means 8,500 Btu per kilowatt-hour, or about 2.5 units of heat per unit of electricity. A furnace's AFUE is a percentage of the fuel's energy that reaches the house: 92% means 8% goes up the flue.
So for 50 MMBtu of annual heating, a heat pump at HSPF2 8.5 uses 5,588 kWh for the 95% of the load it covers, plus a little backup resistance heat for the rest, which adds 733 kWh because resistance heat is exactly 100% efficient and costs full price. At 18.2 cents that is $1,150. A 92% furnace burns 543 therms for the same heat, which at $1.61 is $875.
The heat pump loses that round on fuel cost and wins the next one on cooling, because one machine handles both: 18 MMBtu of cooling at SEER2 15 uses 1,200 kWh against 1,259 kWh for a SEER2 14.3 air conditioner on its own circuit. The difference is $11 a year, which is real but not a reason to buy anything.
A heat pump at HSPF2 8.5 and a furnace at 92% AFUE break even when the electricity price in cents per kilowatt-hour is about nine times the gas price in dollars per therm. With gas at $1.61 that line falls at 15 cents. At 18.2 cents the heat pump costs about 30% more per unit of heat delivered, which is why gas wins on national averages. Propane at about $2.73 a therm moves the line to 25 cents, and most of the country sits below it, which is why those houses flip.
Where a heat pump wins, and where it does not
Four variables decide the outcome in a real house, and only one of them is the equipment.
| Situation | Ten-year winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Gas heat, AC also due for replacement, average US prices | Furnace + AC | Gas delivers heat for about a quarter less per MMBtu; the install gap is small |
| Propane heat at $2.50 a gallon (about $2.73 a therm) | Heat pump | Propane costs nearly twice as much per delivered unit as natural gas |
| Heating oil at $3.90 a gallon (about $2.81 a therm) | Heat pump | Same reason, plus no tank, delivery or burner service |
| Electric resistance heat or baseboard | Heat pump | Replaces 100%-efficient heat with 250%-efficient heat |
| Cheap hydro power, 12–14 cents a kWh | Heat pump | Fuel cost per delivered unit falls below the gas price |
| Expensive electricity, 27–30 cents, with cheap gas | Furnace + AC | New England and California rates invert the national math |
| No ductwork, whole house to condition | Furnace + AC | Adding ducts to a ductless house can double the installed price |
| One or two rooms only | Mini-split | Per-zone cost is far below either whole-house option |
The install gap has narrowed enough that fuel decides almost everything. The two ranges now overlap, and in some markets the heat pump is the cheaper install because it replaces two machines with one. The federal credit used to hide a $2,000 loss in the operating-cost comparison; without it, a house with cheap gas and expensive electricity is a straightforward no.
Rebates that survived
The 2022 climate law's Home Energy Rebates are appropriations, not tax credits, and the 2025 budget law did not claw back money that states had already received. Two programs exist: HEEHR, usually called HEAR, which pays part of the cost of electric appliances including heat pumps for income-qualified households, and HOMES, which pays for measured whole-home savings.
Deployment has been slow and uneven. As of October 2026, about ten states plus DC were taking applications for at least one program, 35 had not launched, and a few had closed after spending their allocation. California is the clearest case: its single-family HEAR round was fully reserved statewide by February 24, 2026, with a waitlist only.
| Status | States | What it means for a heat pump quote |
|---|---|---|
| Taking applications | DC, Georgia (paused, reopening), Indiana, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Wisconsin | Income limits apply; most pay the contractor directly |
| Open with limits or a waitlist | Arizona, Maine, Michigan, Utah, West Virginia | Some now cover electric-to-electric replacements only |
| Closed after spending the allocation | California (single-family), Colorado (single-family) | Waitlist only; do not count on it in a budget |
| Not launched | Texas and about 34 others, including Florida, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Washington | No date; ask the state energy office, not the contractor |
Utility rebates are the more reliable money and the more variable one. Xcel Energy in Colorado, for example, pays $900 a ton for a standard heat pump and $2,250 a ton for cold-climate equipment, which closes most of the sticker gap between the two. Programs like that change annually and are usually listed on the utility's own rebate page rather than on a contractor's flyer.
What to demand from a cold-climate quote
If you live where January means single digits, the label to look for is not "ENERGY STAR." It is "ENERGY STAR Cold Climate," which requires two measurements the base label never tests: a coefficient of performance of at least 1.75 at 5°F, and heating capacity at 5°F of at least 70% of rated capacity at 47°F. Cold-climate models also carry a higher HSPF2 floor, 8.1 for ducted systems and 8.5 for ductless.
| Measure | Standard | Cold Climate |
|---|---|---|
| COP at 5°F | not tested | 1.75 or higher |
| Capacity at 5°F vs. 47°F | not tested | 70% or higher |
| HSPF2, ducted split | 7.8 | 8.1 |
| HSPF2, ductless mini-split | 7.8 | 8.5 |
The 70% number is the one that matters on the coldest night. Even a cold-climate unit is allowed to fall to 70% of its rated output at 5°F, and below the local design temperature it may need help. That help is either electric resistance strips, which cost $200 to $500 installed and run at a coefficient of performance of exactly 1.0, or a retained furnace in a dual-fuel setup, which costs $3,000 to $6,000 and runs at 95% AFUE. In a mild climate, no backup is a reasonable bet. In a cold one, budget for some.
Refrigerant and the 2025 equipment change
New residential systems sold since January 1, 2025 must use a refrigerant with a global warming potential below 700, which retired R-410A for new equipment in favor of R-454B or R-32. The change added roughly 8% to 15% to installed prices through 2025 as contractors absorbed new leak-detection requirements, recovery equipment and certification, and pricing has been normalizing through 2026. It also means an R-410A outdoor unit cannot be paired with an A2L indoor coil, so a partial replacement is no longer a shortcut.
Lifespan, refrigerant and the fifteen-year truth
Ten years is the fair comparison because it fits inside both machines' lives. Heat pumps last 10 to 15 years, furnaces 15 to 20. Compare at 15 years and the heat pump usually needs a replacement compressor or a full outdoor unit while the furnace is still running, which is a cost the ten-year table hides. Run the calculator at 15 years as well as 10 before deciding, and treat the difference between the two answers as the risk premium on the newer technology.
One more cost belongs in the file: maintenance. Both systems run $150 to $300 a year. A heat pump benefits more from it, because a dirty coil or a low charge costs efficiency in both seasons, and skipping it is how a heat pump earns its reputation for high bills.
Get the AHRI certificate with the model numbers. Ask for the words "Cold Climate" if you need them, not "ENERGY STAR." Confirm the quote states the installed price, electrical work, permit and haul-away separately. Ask whether any state or utility rebate is applied at the point of sale or reimbursed later. And check the quote for a $2,000 federal line, because that credit no longer exists for 2026 work.
Frequently asked questions
Is there still a $2,000 federal tax credit for a heat pump in 2026?
No. Section 25C ended for property placed in service after December 31, 2025, and section 25D ended for expenditures after the same date. Equipment installed in 2026 cannot generate either credit. Installations completed by December 31, 2025 can still be claimed on a 2025 return.
Is a heat pump cheaper than a furnace over ten years?
It depends on two prices, not on the equipment. With national average prices, 18.2 cents a kilowatt-hour and $1.61 a therm, a 92% furnace costs less to run and comes out about $1,650 ahead over ten years including installation. With propane, oil, electric resistance heat or electricity under about 14 cents, the heat pump usually wins.
How much more does a cold-climate heat pump cost?
Typically 20% to 40% more than a standard unit, and the installed range for cold-climate equipment runs from about $12,000 to $32,500 depending on size and market. Utility rebates sometimes pay more for cold-climate models, which can narrow or erase the gap.
Do I need backup heat with a heat pump?
Not always. A cold-climate unit holds at least 70% of rated capacity at 5°F, which covers most of the country's design conditions. Where winter design temperatures go below zero, most installers still specify resistance strips or keep the existing furnace as dual fuel.
What efficiency numbers should I compare?
For heating, HSPF2 for the heat pump against AFUE for the furnace, knowing that one is a ratio and the other a percentage. For cooling, SEER2 for both the heat pump and the air conditioner. Anything printed as plain HSPF or SEER is from the older test procedure and is not directly comparable.
Sources
- IRS, FAQs on the modification of sections 25C, 25D and related credits (FS-2025-05), August 21, 2025.
- IRS, 2025 Instructions for Form 5695, Residential Energy Credits (termination of the credits).
- U.S. EIA, Electric Power Monthly, end-use retail prices, August 2026 (residential average 18.16 cents/kWh).
- U.S. EIA, Natural Gas Monthly, Table 20: residential price by state, 2026 year to date.
- ENERGY STAR, Air source heat pumps: program requirements and cold-climate criteria.
- U.S. DOE, Home Energy Rebates program notices and state program pages, checked October 2026.
- EPA, AIM Act Technology Transitions: refrigerant restrictions by sector.
How this was checked: the credit termination was read from IRS Fact Sheet 2025-05 and the 2025 Form 5695 instructions, not from a contractor page. Installed cost ranges come from installer-reported projects (ARS national data, January 2025 to January 2026) and national cost surveys published in 2026; they are ranges, not quotes, and local labor markets move them. Fuel prices are EIA residential averages for August 2026, converted to dollars per therm at 10.37 therms per thousand cubic feet. Efficiency criteria are ENERGY STAR's cold-climate thresholds. The examples were computed with the same formulas the calculator above uses. This article is general information, not engineering, tax or contracting advice; a Manual J load calculation and a written quote for your house decide the real numbers.
Comments
Post a Comment