2027 ACA Dec 15 Deadline: 5 Plan-Choice Mistakes That Cost Money

2027 coverage year · ACA marketplace

Updated November 16, 2026 · Every figure below was read from the CMS plan year 2027 fact sheet (October 30, 2026), IRS guidance or HealthCare.gov on that date · IssueJupJup US editorial desk · General information, not tax or insurance advice

December 15 is the last day to choose a 2027 HealthCare.gov plan that starts on January 1. Enroll from December 16 through January 15 and coverage starts February 1 instead, which leaves a month with no insurance unless you have something else in place.

The five mistakes below often cost more than the difference between two plans on the same shelf: letting the marketplace renew your plan for you, shopping on the monthly premium alone, assuming your doctors and drugs are still in the network, ignoring the new HSA rules, and entering an income figure you never re-checked.

On October 30, 2026 CMS said every HealthCare.gov shopper now has access to HSA-eligible plans, with 35 of them on average for eligible enrollees — a change that turns a cheap bronze plan into a usable savings vehicle for people who can fund the account.

Key takeaways

  • Dec 15 for a January 1 start, Jan 15 for the end of open enrollment, Feb 1 for anything enrolled after Dec 15. A plan does not take effect until the first premium is paid.
  • Average benchmark silver premiums for 2027 are up 13% to about $703 a month for a 40-year-old. Doing nothing means paying that increase with a subsidy still calculated on last year's income.
  • Bronze and catastrophic plans now count as high-deductible health plans (IRS Notice 2026-5), so an HSA can pair with a cheap premium — if you have no general-purpose health FSA and no Medicare.
  • The subsidy structure is unchanged from 2026: no credit at all above 400% of the poverty guideline, which is $63,840 for one person on 2027 coverage.

Most 2027 coverage guides explain the subsidy formula, and that formula matters. But the money people actually lose this month is lost in plan selection, not in the formula: a renewal nobody read, a $50 premium hiding a $9,000 deductible, a doctor who left the network, an HSA they assumed they could not open. This is the checklist version. It takes ten minutes, and every item is something you can verify on the plan's own documents before you click enroll.

2027 ACA December 15 enrollment deadline and January 1 coverage start
2027 coverage: enroll by December 15 for a January 1 start; open enrollment closes January 15, 2027. Source: CMS plan year 2027 fact sheet, October 30, 2026.

What actually happens on December 15

Open enrollment for 2027 runs from November 1, 2026 through January 15, 2027 on HealthCare.gov. Within that window there is one date that decides whether you are insured on New Year's Day. Enroll and pay the first premium by December 15 and coverage begins January 1. Enroll between December 16 and January 15 and coverage begins February 1.

Two details trip people up. The first is payment: selecting a plan is not the same as having one, and coverage does not start until the first premium is paid, so a plan picked on December 14 and paid on December 20 is a February 1 start in practice. The second is geography. December 15 is the HealthCare.gov clock; several state-run marketplaces set a later one for a January 1 start.

Enrollment date and coverage start, 2027 plan year
Enroll and pay byCoverage beginsWhere this applies
December 15, 2026January 1, 2027All HealthCare.gov states and most state marketplaces
December 16 – January 15February 1, 2027HealthCare.gov states
December 31, 2026January 1, 2027California, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Virginia, Washington
December 23, 2026January 1, 2027Massachusetts, Rhode Island
After January 15, 2027No open enrollmentOnly with a special enrollment period

Idaho is the one state where enrollment closes on December 15 rather than continuing into January. California, the District of Columbia, New Jersey, New York and Rhode Island keep their doors open until January 31; Massachusetts closes January 23 and Virginia January 29. If your state runs its own exchange, check that exchange rather than the federal date, because the January 1 deadline is not the same everywhere.

Mistake 1: letting the plan renew itself

Do nothing and the marketplace generally renews you into your current plan, or a comparable one if yours is discontinued, with your advance premium tax credit continuing at the income estimate you gave last year. That default is the single most expensive item on this list, because two things moved underneath it.

Premiums rose. KFF's analysis of final 2027 rates puts the average benchmark silver premium at about $703 a month for a 40-year-old, up 13% from 2026 and 42% above 2025. Increases average 11% in HealthCare.gov states and 16% in the states that run their own marketplaces. Your income probably did not rise 13%, and your credit did not adjust to the new premium unless you updated the application.

Plans changed shape. Insurers moved counties, changed networks, added prior authorization and repriced drug tiers. A renewal notice is a legal document, not a summary, and the plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage is where the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum for 2027 actually appear. Compare the 2027 numbers with what you spent in 2026, not with what the brochure says about averages.

The renewal test

Last year's deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, network and drug list, beside this year's. If three of the four moved, the plan you had is not the plan you are being renewed into, and you are choosing it again by default.

The enrollment numbers show what happens when people stop checking. Effectuated marketplace enrollment — the people who pay and stay enrolled — fell 12%, about 2.6 million people, between early 2025 and February 2026. The Congressional Budget Office projects 13.1 million marketplace enrollees in 2027, down from a peak of 22.4 million in 2025. Most of that decline is households that lost a credit, not households that found a job with benefits.

Mistake 2: shopping on the premium alone

A $0 premium plan and a $40 premium plan in the same county are not $40 apart in cost. They are the difference between a deductible you can meet in one emergency and one you cannot. The premium is the only number quoted in the first screen, which is exactly why it should not be the deciding number.

Three numbers decide what a plan actually costs you: the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum, and whether the plan is silver. Cost-sharing reductions — the second subsidy, separate from the premium credit — exist only on silver plans, and only up to 250% of the poverty guideline. At 150% of poverty a silver plan pays 94% of covered costs; between 150% and 200% it pays 87%; between 200% and 250% it pays 73%. A bronze plan at the same income pays about 60%. For a household with regular prescriptions or a planned procedure, silver with cost-sharing reductions is frequently cheaper than bronze with a smaller sticker price, and the difference is not visible until you open the plan details.

Catastrophic plans are the other trap, in the opposite direction. CMS reports that the average lowest-cost catastrophic premium is nearly 10% cheaper than the next lowest-cost option at other metal levels, and catastrophic plans cover preventive care with no copay and three primary care visits before the deductible. But they are open only to people under 30, or to people who qualify for a hardship or affordability exemption. A 45-year-old who clicks the cheapest card and expects to keep it will be rejected at the end of the application.

Mistake 3: assuming your doctors and drugs are covered

Networks are plan-specific and they change every year, including between plans sold by the same insurer in the same county. Two checks, both quick, both on the plan's own site rather than a comparison site: search the plan's provider directory for each doctor you actually use, and search the formulary for each prescription by dose and brand, not by the generic class.

Then look at how the drug is covered, because a drug can be "covered" and still cost $300 a month. Tiers 1 and 2 are cheap, tier 3 is where the coinsurance starts, and specialty drugs are frequently placed on a tier with 30% to 40% coinsurance until the out-of-pocket maximum is met. If anyone in the household takes a specialty drug, run the annual cost against the plan's maximum before comparing premiums. A $60 a month premium difference disappears quickly against a $2,000 drug cost difference.

One thing you do not need to check is preventive care. Every ACA-compliant plan, catastrophic included, covers the recommended preventive services with no cost sharing in network, whether or not the deductible has been met.

Mistake 4: skipping the HSA question

This is the item that changed most for 2027, and the one most shoppers will not think to ask. A health savings account is triple-tax-advantaged: contributions are deductible or pre-tax, growth is tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified medical costs are tax-free. The catch has always been that you must be enrolled in a high-deductible health plan, and most marketplace bronze plans did not qualify.

That changed. Under IRS Notice 2026-5, a bronze or catastrophic plan sold through an exchange is treated as a high-deductible plan, even where it misses the usual minimum deductible or out-of-pocket rules, starting with months after December 31, 2025. CMS's October 30 fact sheet describes the result: every HealthCare.gov shopper has access to HSA-eligible plans, eligible enrollees have 35 of them on average, which CMS calls a more than 1,000% increase over the prior baseline.

2027 HSA contribution limits and which marketplace plans qualify
2027 HSA limits and the plans that now count as high-deductible. Sources: IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24; IRS Notice 2026-5; CMS fact sheet, October 30, 2026.

The 2027 limits are $4,500 for self-only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, with another $1,000 at age 55 or older (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24). Contributed through payroll, the money also escapes the 7.65% Medicare and Social Security tax: $4,500 through a cafeteria plan saves $344 in payroll tax on top of income tax, which at a 22% federal rate is about $1,334 in total for a self-only saver, and roughly double that for a family at the $9,000 limit. Contribute outside payroll and you keep the income tax deduction but lose the payroll tax benefit.

What still blocks an HSA contribution in 2027
Blocking coverageWhat to do instead
General-purpose health FSA through an employerA limited-purpose FSA (dental and vision only) does not block HSA eligibility
Medicare enrollmentContributions must stop; the look-back is six months for Part A
Being claimed as a dependent on someone else's returnNo contribution until you file your own return
Other disqualifying coverage (some TRICARE and VA situations)Check IRS Publication 969 for your specific case

One more 2027 wrinkle worth knowing: a direct primary care membership no longer disqualifies you, as long as the fee stays at or below $150 a month, or $300 for family coverage (Rev. Proc. 2026-24), and the fee itself can be paid from the HSA. Before this year, that arrangement was treated as a health plan and shut the account down.

Mistake 5: guessing your income

The premium tax credit is a reconciliation, not a discount. You receive advance payments during the year based on an estimate, and the actual credit is settled when you file. Above 400% of the poverty guideline there is no credit at all — $63,840 for one person, $132,000 for a family of four on 2027 coverage — and the repayment caps that normally limit how much a household must return do not apply above that line. Every dollar of advance credit has to go back.

That is the structure, and the full math is in the 2027 subsidy limit guide. What matters for December is narrower: the number you enter has to be a projection for 2027, not last year's salary, and it has to be updated if it changes mid-year. A raise, a bonus, a severance payment, a required minimum distribution or a large capital gain all land in the year they are received. Report a change in March and you get eleven months of correctly sized payments; report it in April of the following year and you get one large repayment.

If you are within a few thousand dollars of the 400% line, the levers that lower modified adjusted gross income are still available before December 31: a traditional 401(k) deferral of up to $25,500 in 2027, a traditional IRA contribution of up to $7,500, an HSA contribution, and the self-employed health insurance deduction. The 2027 figures for those accounts are in the 2027 retirement contribution guide.

The 10-minute check before you enroll

  1. Open the 2027 Summary of Benefits and Coverage for your current plan. Write down the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum. If you cannot find the document, that is the answer: the plan changed.
  2. Compare three plans, not one: your renewal, the benchmark silver plan in your county, and the cheapest plan that keeps your doctors. Price all three at your actual income, not at $0 premium.
  3. Search the provider directory for every doctor you used in 2026, and the formulary for every prescription. Screenshot what you find; directories are updated without notice.
  4. Answer the HSA question for 2027. Do you have a general-purpose health FSA or Medicare? If not, does the plan you want say "HSA-eligible" on its own plan page, and can you fund $4,500 or $9,000 over the year?
  5. Update the income on the application even if you keep the same plan. The plan does not need your attention; the application does.
  6. Pay the first premium and confirm the coverage start date on the confirmation screen before you close the tab.

If you miss December 15

You are not uninsured for the year, only for January. Enrolling between December 16 and January 15 gives a February 1 start, so the cost of a missed deadline is one month of coverage. That month is not free: a hospital stay in January is paid at full price, and a new prescription is paid at retail. If you are enrolling late because you are deciding between two plans, compare the difference in annual cost against the cost of one month of exposure before you decide it is worth waiting.

After January 15, enrollment reopens only with a special enrollment period, which is triggered by a qualifying life event — losing other coverage, marriage, a birth, a move — and generally runs 60 days from the event. Losing a job-based plan mid-year qualifies; letting a plan lapse for non-payment does not. Households under 138% of the poverty guideline in a Medicaid expansion state belong in Medicaid, which enrolls year-round, so the January 15 date does not apply to them.

Frequently asked questions

Is December 15 the last day of open enrollment?

No. It is the last day to enroll and have coverage start January 1. Open enrollment on HealthCare.gov continues through January 15, 2027, with coverage starting February 1 for anything enrolled after December 15. Several state marketplaces close later, and Idaho closes on December 15.

Are all 2027 marketplace plans HSA-eligible?

No. CMS says every HealthCare.gov shopper has access to HSA-eligible plans, with 35 on average for eligible enrollees, but that describes availability, not every plan. A plan qualifies only if it is labeled HSA-eligible on its own plan page, and your personal eligibility depends on having no other disqualifying coverage — a general-purpose health FSA or Medicare, for example.

Do I have to do anything if I want to keep the same plan?

Yes, one thing: update your income estimate on the application. The plan itself will generally renew automatically, but the advance premium tax credit continues at your old estimate while the premium rises. If your actual 2027 income differs, the difference is settled at filing, sometimes as a repayment.

Can I switch plans after December 15?

You can still enroll in a different 2027 plan through January 15 in HealthCare.gov states; the difference is that coverage starts February 1 instead of January 1. State marketplaces with later deadlines, such as California's January 31, give you more room.

Is a cheap bronze plan with an HSA better than silver?

It depends on whether you will spend past the deductible. Bronze with an HSA works when you can fund the account and expect low medical use, because the premium is lower and the contribution is tax-advantaged. Silver wins when your income is at or below 250% of the poverty guideline, because cost-sharing reductions raise the plan's share of covered costs to 73%–94%, which bronze does not offer at any income.

What if my income changes in the middle of 2027?

Report it on the application rather than waiting. A drop in income can increase the credit for the remaining months; a rise reduces it and avoids a repayment at filing. Either way, the reconciliation at filing uses your final figures, so an early report only makes the monthly numbers closer to the truth.

Sources

CMS, Plan Year 2027 Marketplace Plans and Prices Fact Sheet (October 30, 2026) — 100 plans and five to six insurers on average, more than 75% of shoppers with access to premiums at or below $50, 35 HSA-eligible plans on average, catastrophic premiums nearly 10% below the next lowest option. · IRS, Notice 2026-5 (bronze and catastrophic exchange plans treated as HDHPs) and Rev. Proc. 2026-24 (2027 HSA limits of $4,500 and $9,000, $150/$300 direct primary care limit). · IRS, Rev. Proc. 2026-26 (2027 applicable percentage table, top rate 10.22%). · HealthCare.gov, 2027 enrollment dates. · KFF, 9 Things to Watch for the 2027 ACA Open Enrollment Period (November 6, 2026) — benchmark premium $703 and +13%, 2026 effectuated enrollment down 12% to 19.2 million, CBO projection of 13.1 million for 2027. · healthinsurance.org, Open enrollment deadlines (updated October 28, 2026) — state marketplace dates. · HHS, 2026 poverty guidelines (91 Fed. Reg. 1797, January 15, 2026), which set the $63,840 cliff for one person on 2027 coverage.

How this was checked: plan counts, HSA plan availability and the $50 premium threshold come from the CMS fact sheet of October 30, 2026; HSA contribution limits and the direct primary care threshold from IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24; the HDHP treatment of bronze and catastrophic plans from IRS Notice 2026-5; enrollment dates from HealthCare.gov and, for state-run marketplaces, from healthinsurance.org's dated table. Premium averages are KFF's analysis of final 2027 rates. The payroll-tax arithmetic is 7.65% of $4,500 and of $9,000, plus federal income tax at a 22% marginal rate; your own bracket may differ. This article is general information, not tax, legal or insurance advice — your plan documents and the marketplace's eligibility determination control.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Heat Pump vs. Furnace in 2026: The $2,000 Credit Is Gone

2027 401(k) Limits: $25,500, $34,000 at 50+, $37,250 at 60-63

S Corp Reasonable Compensation 2026: Salary Rules and the Math